PON Report | Keddietruth

kmik
Full Member

Posts: 215

PON Report May 16, 2023 5:06:49 GMT Hope likes this

Quote

Post by kmik on May 16, 2023 5:06:49 GMT

There's no way this is an original "official" PON list written by LE. Too many unimportant names included such as:

*Jimmy Bosco (kid who reported the odor in Keddie that later turned out to be a dead cat)
*Dr. Riser (he was consulted on Justin's behavior)
*John Gay (found a comb along the RR tracks weeks after the murders - imagine that)
*Psychics and people with "visions"

Too many unimportant names excluded:

*Barbara Shearer (Phillip Shearers mom and Glenna Meeks sister)
*Jim the ex (just happened to have been staying with the Meeks during this timeframe, was reported to LE by Glenna to have gone over to Marty's on the 15th where he witnessed Marty "burning" his wood stove, and was an alibi for Wade Meeks along with ______________ and Wade's mom)
*____________ (was an alibi for Wade - I'll say this probably his older sister but why leave her name out??)
*Reno counselor (that Marty supposedly "confessed" to)
*Roseanna Knowlan (Jehovah Witness "friend" of Sue's who called the PCSO on the morning of the murders)

Are we seriously supposed to believe these people were not included on this list?? They are in official reports so why wouldn't they be on this list? My guess would be Josh.

Posted by brickMar 3, 2022 at 6:43am

Josh posted some of it. His version was highly redacted and edited. He was too much of Sheila's stooge to post the truth.

Well "Brick" if Josh was too much of Sheila's stooge to post the truth then whose stooge are you? Let's see you post the TRUTH.

snoho17
Administrator

Yeah I'll hold your beer

Posts: 641

PON Report May 16, 2023 5:39:51 GMT kmik likes this

Quote

Post by snoho17 on May 16, 2023 5:39:51 GMT

Thanks for this Kmik! 100%! It's weird, some of those notations on that list are a brief from that persons interview, or some other pertinent thing about their statements. But others skip right over their info given, it's not until we see the actual interviews that we realize some of these people had way more relevant things to say than just "in bar that night" or "saw Dana and Johnny".

Hope
Administrator

Posts: 954

PON Report May 16, 2023 7:45:44 GMT kmik and snoho17 like this

Quote

Post by Hope on May 16, 2023 7:45:44 GMT

I think so too kmik. The actual PON report was never posted online, only this transcribed version. Even back then it was strange how some reports were uploaded in their original form, others transcribed instead. It's safe to assume anytime transcription was chosen it's because something was omitted before publishing. The names you mentioned most certainly were included in the original, PCSO included everyone & their mother no matter how insignificant their info.

In the therapist's case his name was probably excluded because he was promised his anonymity in the documentary. And for all we know his official PON entry said "Neighbor said Martin Smartt confessed to him. VD denies, info came from Smartt's wife".

Cheeseman's entry remained. PCSO wouldn't have included his and then leave out the therapists. Just like it's impossible to believe they didn't speak with/include Phillips mom after he confessed to her.

Roseanna was the first tip DT got that morning. And I can't see them leaving out Jim the ex, he was there, an out of towner staying with the victims best friends. What PCSO just ignored and pretended he didn't exist? And the older sisters?

Marty's entry was always interesting to me, the part about him being upset his son was being interrogated. Where's that interview? When did it occur and why hasn't it been released.

SMARTT, MARTIN

Lived Keddie, in bar 4/11/81, upset @ son being interrogated consent search on his house, took polygraph test

<THOMAS>/<CRIM>/ <BRADLEY>