Post by Hope on Aug 26, 2023 22:58:14 GMT
This is exactly why you shouldn't claim to have solved a homicide case when in reality you had nothing more than a theory. A theory that originated in a documentary someone else put the time, energy and work into creating. It was the personal theory of a small handful of people who happened to be very close to the case, therefore the documentary heavily focused on their theory.
You can't claim you solved a case based on a ripped off theory, forum discussions and 1/75th of the available case files.
It's blatantly obvious that everything in the full case file pertaining to MMB has been publicly available since Josh released them 10+ years ago. Not one additional potentially incriminating document has been released since he came into possession of "every file known to still be in existence". Oh, but he's come into possession of plenty which disprove his decade old claims, he just makes sure the public never gets to see or hear about those.
Hmm, let's see he just keeps finding more and more liars now that more files other than only those focusing on Marty & Bo are available. It is so substantial, he's trying to back himself out that corner he put himself in. Except he can't because he "solved the case in 2010". Now all he can do is add more and more people into this convoluted mess and accuse them of being involved in the murders.
And of course he can always use his claims of LE coverup to fallback on & explain away whatever doesn't fit. And can't forget all those falsified reports with faked dates. It's kinda funny how he believes PCSO falsified reports because that's what he does!! He's the one cropping reports and removing lines, entire entries and even full pages/days of investigative work from official PCSO files before publicly posting them. Redacting names and then misrepresenting the report as being related to a completely different person & occurrence.
Cropping & misrepresenting DNA reports, knowing full well what he was attempting to do there. Withholding pertinent information and twisting bits of legit information into a mess of misinformation.
He had no choice but to remove his tunnel vision glasses and admit to himself what we have been saying for years - there are many other people who deserve a closer look. And those people make better suspects than MMB+. He can't publicly admit this and that's what we are watching unfold right now.
It's c.2012 all over again except this time different people are his main focus & 'suspects'. Can't remove MMB at this point so just claim they were all involved. We'll be seeing another dozen people added as he digs into everyone associated with these people. This is exactly how MMB began. Don't believe a word of what you hear unless you see it with your own two eyes. An official LE report, nothing else, summaries and typed 'transcripts' are nothing more than an altered & twisted version of the official report. Removing, adding or changing just enough so it aligns with his theory better but also completely misconstrues the facts. Dmac's little recreations are what I've come to call them.
We have an updated timeline of J&D sightings too, we went through everything old & new, official reports, nothing changed or left out. I'll get it posted. But spoiler alert, practically every single person connected with J&D had differing statements. The most significant all occurred between the hours of 10pm-2am. Several appeared to be withholding information which likely caused these inconsistencies and discrepancies between people. Does that mean every single one of them are involved together in this murder? Heck no. Does it prove any single one of them alone did? Nope again. It does show that there may be something there which deserves a closer look. Perhaps there was something involving j&d which led to these homicides. These were all just kids and I'm sure they were scared. But he refuses to admit the existence of other potential motives. Instead with have this bizarre motive involving half the county wanting Sue dead because she had a nonexistent affair with Marty.
And wow, now it turns out that Donna, "the biggest liar in the case", may not have been a liar after all!?! Shocking. Additional reports confirm many things she told PCSO had all been proven to be truthful?! How about that? But of course, she's still lying when it comes to anything that doesn't fit a theory. Make it make sense. Perhaps it shouldn't have been decided she was a crazy drunk xyz simply because her statements didn't pertain to Marty & Bo. Accused her and multiple others of inserting themselves and lying for the attention. Get the F outta here. I'd say it's the opposite, imo all those "crazy attention seeking liars" were the last people who wanted anything to do with LE. It's funny how they're all from the same circle as well. With Donna, I see a young girl who was severely traumatized by the murder of friends. And scared. She & several others may very well have had legitimate information. No one wants to come right out and name names, especially when no one else is talking. IMO it's easy to see why certain people may have told a combination of truth mixed in with evasiveness & 'lies'. BTW, her mother also told PCSO that Donna did borrow her sister's car that afternoon & when she came home she said she had given Johnny & Dana a ride to the store. So she did see them at least once that day. Donna was also the person who first informed the Dorris' that Dana had been murdered. Before PCSO notified them. And I'd bet anything she didn't learn that information from Sheila like she said. Sheila was the only name she could say without people questioning it. So, how did she really know so early? I can see why those "stupid pigs" like Stoy decided to revisit her year after year.
I've lost count of the number of people accused of being involved in this murder. Does this sound remotely possible to anyone?? Every new addition makes it even more ridiculous than before. Keddie28's "solve" is no different than if any of us found a way to tie together every single individual we felt deserved a closer look and then claim we solved it. Except most people know it's not ok to publicly accuse people of murder, wish death & torture upon them or take it to other such extreme levels.
Adding Sheila into it. Ridiculous nonsense. So according to him, two grown men believed it was a smart idea to include a 14 year old girl they didn't even know into their plans for murdering her mother. Not only did they not know her beyond sight but they blindly trusted she wouldn't immediately tell her mom or LE of their plans? And on the highly unlikely event that any 14 year old girl would jump on board with their offer , they weren't at all concerned with the added risk her involvement added? That she wouldn't talk to her friends or even confess & tell all to LE afterwards? Or the potential emotional reaction she may have afterwards, bringing attention to herself and them?
MMB or not, Sheila had nothing to do with the murder of her family. It's not even a remote possibility in my mind. If people were aware of everything she has done to help get this case solved then they wouldn't entertain it either. In the past, she successfully got Vidocq to look into the case. Unfortunately, PCSO declined to work with them. That opportunity was lost because Vidocq can't do anything without involvement from the investigating department. Same outcome with a private investigator she had who was willing and interested in helping. Countless letters & emails to anyone & everyone. Unsolved Mysteries, America's Most Wanted, cold case tv shows, news outlets.
And the TRUTH is that she is still actively doing these things. If she was involved, if she knew who or that people close to her was responsible, do you think she'd be doing these things?
If she was involved would she be in contact with the best DNA Laboratory in the country regarding advanced DNA testing, contact she initiated? Or request the assistance of an independent cold case investigator? Opening her entire life and full access to everything available to him? No, she wouldn't. She's doing it because she hopes this case can be solved one day. And those are just two examples of what is really going on. I'm F'n tired of keeping our mouths shut on what we know. There have been so many lost opportunities in this case and I don't understand why. It'll all come out one day.
Sheila's never been hiding, she's never been scared. She chooses to not interact with a specific person and that's her decision to make. And it's a smart decision, the right one imo. Just because someone is louder & meaner doesn't mean that person is right. IMO, none of the 101 people he has publicly named and accused were participants in this homicide. Please continue to do your own research when it comes to this case and believe what you hear without verifying it yourself.
Fuck you keddie28. You've hurt enough people and ruined enough lives. No need to do the same thing to more people. This case needs a fresh start maybe it's time to drop the act and lay it out there, stop protecting a theory. Isn't solving this case most important?
You can't claim you solved a case based on a ripped off theory, forum discussions and 1/75th of the available case files.
It's blatantly obvious that everything in the full case file pertaining to MMB has been publicly available since Josh released them 10+ years ago. Not one additional potentially incriminating document has been released since he came into possession of "every file known to still be in existence". Oh, but he's come into possession of plenty which disprove his decade old claims, he just makes sure the public never gets to see or hear about those.
Hmm, let's see he just keeps finding more and more liars now that more files other than only those focusing on Marty & Bo are available. It is so substantial, he's trying to back himself out that corner he put himself in. Except he can't because he "solved the case in 2010". Now all he can do is add more and more people into this convoluted mess and accuse them of being involved in the murders.
And of course he can always use his claims of LE coverup to fallback on & explain away whatever doesn't fit. And can't forget all those falsified reports with faked dates. It's kinda funny how he believes PCSO falsified reports because that's what he does!! He's the one cropping reports and removing lines, entire entries and even full pages/days of investigative work from official PCSO files before publicly posting them. Redacting names and then misrepresenting the report as being related to a completely different person & occurrence.
Cropping & misrepresenting DNA reports, knowing full well what he was attempting to do there. Withholding pertinent information and twisting bits of legit information into a mess of misinformation.
He had no choice but to remove his tunnel vision glasses and admit to himself what we have been saying for years - there are many other people who deserve a closer look. And those people make better suspects than MMB+. He can't publicly admit this and that's what we are watching unfold right now.
It's c.2012 all over again except this time different people are his main focus & 'suspects'. Can't remove MMB at this point so just claim they were all involved. We'll be seeing another dozen people added as he digs into everyone associated with these people. This is exactly how MMB began. Don't believe a word of what you hear unless you see it with your own two eyes. An official LE report, nothing else, summaries and typed 'transcripts' are nothing more than an altered & twisted version of the official report. Removing, adding or changing just enough so it aligns with his theory better but also completely misconstrues the facts. Dmac's little recreations are what I've come to call them.
We have an updated timeline of J&D sightings too, we went through everything old & new, official reports, nothing changed or left out. I'll get it posted. But spoiler alert, practically every single person connected with J&D had differing statements. The most significant all occurred between the hours of 10pm-2am. Several appeared to be withholding information which likely caused these inconsistencies and discrepancies between people. Does that mean every single one of them are involved together in this murder? Heck no. Does it prove any single one of them alone did? Nope again. It does show that there may be something there which deserves a closer look. Perhaps there was something involving j&d which led to these homicides. These were all just kids and I'm sure they were scared. But he refuses to admit the existence of other potential motives. Instead with have this bizarre motive involving half the county wanting Sue dead because she had a nonexistent affair with Marty.
And wow, now it turns out that Donna, "the biggest liar in the case", may not have been a liar after all!?! Shocking. Additional reports confirm many things she told PCSO had all been proven to be truthful?! How about that? But of course, she's still lying when it comes to anything that doesn't fit a theory. Make it make sense. Perhaps it shouldn't have been decided she was a crazy drunk xyz simply because her statements didn't pertain to Marty & Bo. Accused her and multiple others of inserting themselves and lying for the attention. Get the F outta here. I'd say it's the opposite, imo all those "crazy attention seeking liars" were the last people who wanted anything to do with LE. It's funny how they're all from the same circle as well. With Donna, I see a young girl who was severely traumatized by the murder of friends. And scared. She & several others may very well have had legitimate information. No one wants to come right out and name names, especially when no one else is talking. IMO it's easy to see why certain people may have told a combination of truth mixed in with evasiveness & 'lies'. BTW, her mother also told PCSO that Donna did borrow her sister's car that afternoon & when she came home she said she had given Johnny & Dana a ride to the store. So she did see them at least once that day. Donna was also the person who first informed the Dorris' that Dana had been murdered. Before PCSO notified them. And I'd bet anything she didn't learn that information from Sheila like she said. Sheila was the only name she could say without people questioning it. So, how did she really know so early? I can see why those "stupid pigs" like Stoy decided to revisit her year after year.
I've lost count of the number of people accused of being involved in this murder. Does this sound remotely possible to anyone?? Every new addition makes it even more ridiculous than before. Keddie28's "solve" is no different than if any of us found a way to tie together every single individual we felt deserved a closer look and then claim we solved it. Except most people know it's not ok to publicly accuse people of murder, wish death & torture upon them or take it to other such extreme levels.
Adding Sheila into it. Ridiculous nonsense. So according to him, two grown men believed it was a smart idea to include a 14 year old girl they didn't even know into their plans for murdering her mother. Not only did they not know her beyond sight but they blindly trusted she wouldn't immediately tell her mom or LE of their plans? And on the highly unlikely event that any 14 year old girl would jump on board with their offer , they weren't at all concerned with the added risk her involvement added? That she wouldn't talk to her friends or even confess & tell all to LE afterwards? Or the potential emotional reaction she may have afterwards, bringing attention to herself and them?
MMB or not, Sheila had nothing to do with the murder of her family. It's not even a remote possibility in my mind. If people were aware of everything she has done to help get this case solved then they wouldn't entertain it either. In the past, she successfully got Vidocq to look into the case. Unfortunately, PCSO declined to work with them. That opportunity was lost because Vidocq can't do anything without involvement from the investigating department. Same outcome with a private investigator she had who was willing and interested in helping. Countless letters & emails to anyone & everyone. Unsolved Mysteries, America's Most Wanted, cold case tv shows, news outlets.
And the TRUTH is that she is still actively doing these things. If she was involved, if she knew who or that people close to her was responsible, do you think she'd be doing these things?
If she was involved would she be in contact with the best DNA Laboratory in the country regarding advanced DNA testing, contact she initiated? Or request the assistance of an independent cold case investigator? Opening her entire life and full access to everything available to him? No, she wouldn't. She's doing it because she hopes this case can be solved one day. And those are just two examples of what is really going on. I'm F'n tired of keeping our mouths shut on what we know. There have been so many lost opportunities in this case and I don't understand why. It'll all come out one day.
Sheila's never been hiding, she's never been scared. She chooses to not interact with a specific person and that's her decision to make. And it's a smart decision, the right one imo. Just because someone is louder & meaner doesn't mean that person is right. IMO, none of the 101 people he has publicly named and accused were participants in this homicide. Please continue to do your own research when it comes to this case and believe what you hear without verifying it yourself.
Fuck you keddie28. You've hurt enough people and ruined enough lives. No need to do the same thing to more people. This case needs a fresh start maybe it's time to drop the act and lay it out there, stop protecting a theory. Isn't solving this case most important?
